Hailee Steinfeld and Josh Allen’s romance is flourishing, with an insider noting, “Things are progressing really positively.” They’ve been in a relationship since May 2023.

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen and Hollywood actress Hailee Steinfeld have seen their relationship deepen, as per a source close to them speaking to PEOPLE. The star of Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse and the NFL athlete have been investing more time in each other, especially post the football season’s conclusion for Allen. According to the insider, their relationship is thriving, fueled by their shared values of family and ambition. Both are committed to maintaining their privacy and are in sync about it.

Although both 27, the couple has kept their romance relatively low-key, though they’ve been spotted on several outings together. Their public debut was in October when they attended the NHL’s Buffalo Sabres’ season-opener against the New York Rangers. More recently, they were seen together in Laguna Niguel, California, in January, shortly after the Buffalo Bills were eliminated from the NFL playoffs by the Kansas City Chiefs.

A source close to Steinfeld mentioned, “Hailee’s in a great place and would love to settle down if it’s with the right guy.” The couple appears to be taking their time to nurture their relationship, focusing on establishing a solid foundation.

The relationship between Hailee Steinfeld and Josh Allen has been steadily progressing since they were first seen together in May. They were initially described as a “cute couple” who had been “spending time together for a few weeks.” In subsequent months, reports indicated they were still dating and getting to know each other. In October, Steinfeld was seen bonding with Allen’s mother in East Aurora, New York, indicating their relationship’s advancement.

Their journey together includes memorable moments like a sushi date night in New York City, where Allen was photographed affectionately wrapping his arm around Steinfeld. Their public appearances and shared activities offer glimpses into the deepening connection between them.

As their relationship evolves, Hailee Steinfeld and Josh Allen are taking things at their own pace, valuing privacy and nurturing their bond.